Random First Lines: I looked around the schoolgrounds and tapped my foot impatiently. "Alex!"I heard someone shout my name.I looked... : Other » Read

Welcome Visitor: Login to the siteJoin the site


The RHC writes about Harry... View table of contents...

 

Submitted: Mar 19, 2008    Reads: 81    Comments: 3    Likes: 1   


"Of course it is happening inside your head, Harry, but why on earth should that mean that it is not real?"

I feel slightly apprehensive writing a review about this book. Okay, books then. Without a doubt, if we judged how good a book was by how rich it made the author... then Harry Potter is one of the best series of books ever to grace this earth.

Thankfully, we don't. But even so, it's popularity must at least say something of it's quality. It would be wrong for me to call it 'bland' and 'not-worth-the-time-of-day', because if it wasn't worth the time of day, then nobody would of given it the time of day. If you understand me.

Having said this, I do feel that the popularity of the series does go beyond actually how good the book is. Forgive me for saying this, but there may be a possibility that J.K. Rowling was just a reasonably good writer who hit on a very, very good idea. Certainly, the writing itself is alright, the plot lines are magnificent, the characters are... slightly interesting... but the main reason of success for Harry Potter was because it appealled to the mass market. 

If we were honest with ourselves, there are always times in our lives when we wish we could 'magic' things away... and the bizarre new and exiciting world of Wizards seems like only a heartbeat away in ficiton. Part of us longs to be in a Harry Potter book.

Nevertheless, J.K. Rowling's book is still, as with any author, embedded in her own life aswell. It is a thought that has come to me that when anybody, any writer, any poet, publishes a piece of work here on Booksie or elsewhere, they are entering into a personal binding contract with the reader. They are always, no matter what the published matter is like, giving a part of themselves to be read and examined by outsiders.

It is therefore a very dangerous thing to be a writer, but you may get lucky, and you may end up like J.K. Rowling.

If you would like The Rogue Hat Company to review your novel on Booksie, just say. But beware, we will review it as we want to; good or bad... having said that, we are nice people!

 


1

Email this story Email this story | Print Story Print Story | Add to reading list

Comments:

I was skeptical of the whole Harry Potter thing and didn't starting reading the books until a couple of months ago. I though it was all hype.

Last night I was up half the night finishing Goblets of Fire. The series is really good. I think JK Rowling is a darned good writer. Her characters come to life, the writing is crisp without being overwritten, and most importantly, she makes us feel. Very few writers can enter that zone.

I have the Order of the Phoenix by my bed but I'm afraid to start. I need sleep.

I may take you up on your review offer when my book is a bit more edited. Thanks.

Phil

Posted: Mar 19, 2008

Author Comment:

Thanks for commenting! It's good to hear other people's opinions as well! I am no stranger to the 'harry potter hangover'...! Hope you got some sleep! Would love to read and review your book when it's edited. Thanks again,

The Rogue Hat Company

Lionheart
(not registered user)

I read the first few and i slowly drifted away from all the hype. I enjoyed the first few though. But i dont know... everyone has their taste, i think that harry potter is a brilliantly original idea, but i also think it was overrated. Imagine the thoughts going through jk's head when she had to write the 'deathly hollows'(if thats what it was called). you mentioned here that it is a part of someone, and i think you're right. She got really lucky with this and yeah she pretty much wrote what she wanted and because of the success of the previous harry potter books it was going to sell anyway. I think the last books were judged by name not writing....hahahahah!!! Who the hell am i to say? xD I didnt even read all of them hahahahahahaha!!!!!!
Nice review, very honest. I wish i could ask you to read my novel but its not ready, so when it is i will come straight to you, for good or bad :D

Posted: Mar 26, 2008

Author Comment:

ha! thanks for commenting. I would love to review your novel when it's finished. It will be interesting to read her next book that isn't harry potter.

The Rogue Hat Company

I can see what you mean, I've read most of the books. I couldn't finish 3 or 4. And book 5 took me two tries to get through. I did enjoy the last few books, I agree the story was pretty good. I thought a few parts were a little bit of a reach but altogether it worked well. Those aren't really the type of books I'd read, but I think overall it was a decent series. Not a series I'd reread, but it was entertaining.

Posted: Aug 10, 2008

Author Comment:

Thanks for reading and commenting! It's interesting to see what different people think about it :)

TRHC



Add Your Comments:

Your Name:

Spam protection control::

© Copyright 2008 The Rogue Hat Company All rights reserved. The Rogue Hat Company has granted theNextBigWriter, LLC non-exclusive rights to display this work on Booksie.com.

About | News | Contact | Your Account | TheNextBigWriter | Advertise

© 2008 TheNextBigWriter, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Terms under which this service is provided to you. Privacy Policy.