Criss Montgomery has been bullied by Troy Thompson and his gang of idiots for four years now. Why? For being gay. Why does Troy Thompson bully him? He doesn't want to be outed himself. Troy is in love with Criss. When the two get paired up for a project in English, their mutual friend Dylan gets them closer. But when a friend of Troy's finds Criss's diary and posts it on the internet, Criss's trust in Troy is lost. Criss takes drastic measures upon himself and it's Troy's decision what happens; will he save his love or save his reputation?