Why were you the one who stopped and stared?
Why were you the one who walked with swag?
Because you know I’ve gone for guys like that before
Why did you change a little each time,
A new guy came knocking on my front door?
A little more tanned after that surfer boy
And a new way of talking after that Australian guy
And I might just maybe just think why?
Oh right I forgot, you try to hide it
But those puppy dog eyes don’t help your plea
That you’re not absolutely, freaking in love with me
Neither does the dozen white roses
That I know you left on my front step for me
And maybe if you go back to the way you were before
Short blond hair and big blue eyes
And no trash talking all those other guys
I might just maybe just give you a chance.
And once I do you better treat me right
And hold me tight
And take me out the beach at late twilight
And I think you should know that your lips taste like dreamsicles
And bring me back to when we were kids and played pretend
And I feel like this might just maybe just work out.
But you always knew that I wasn’t stable
And this never really lasts for more than a couple months
And that you’ll probably end up in bed with your iPod listening to Taylor Swift
Trying to erase me, my lips, my hair, my eyes from your mind
And you think that I might just maybe just was wrong.