1

Topic: Rules (Read before doing anything else)

The Review Chain is a house where people can get good constructive reviews on their work.

To sum it up you review someone’s piece and then someone else reviews yours.
This is how it works:
•The first person asks for a review on one of their pieces.
•The second person then gives the first person a constructive review. They can then ask for one of their piece’s to be reviewed.
•The third person then gives the second person a constructive review and then asks for one of their piece’s to be reviewed.
And on it goes, like a chain.
You have to review the exact person’s before you, which is the most recent one, not the one that was two or three above. Also you need to review the specific work they ask for, not just anyone of their works. Please say what you have reviewed, it just keeps it more organised. Please leave the review on the work's page, not in the forums.
It has to be a new review. If someone asks for something to be reviewed and you reviewed it awhile ago, then it does not count. You have to give the review after they’ve asked for it.
You can only ask for one piece to be reviewed at a time, and if it is a novel, only one chapter. You can specify a chapter but if no particular chapter is mentioned then it can be any. If they give a review but don't say what they want reviewed, review anything as long as it fits in the same category.
You can give an option of what you want to be reviewed. You can give the reviewer a choice of multiple works of which they can choose one to review.

Now the most important thing is that the review has to be constructive. A constructive review is not ‘I liked it. Keep it up.’ You need to state some particular things you liked about it and WHY. Also state some things that you didn’t like and WHY. Please do not state something you didn't like and not explain why, because they will not know how they can improve. Some points that you could comment on:
•Plot      •Character’s       •Dialogue       •Writing style        •Grammar/ spelling- paragraphs, tense, commas, etc.       •Opening/ middle/ end
•Anything else
For the review to be considered constructive you need to state at least one thing you like and why and at least one thing you didn’t like and why. You must at least a review of 100 word- if it is constructive this isn't hard. The more you say the more the writer can improve.

If you feel that you have been unfairly reviewed; so the reviewer hasn’t been helpful or said very little, or if you accidentally got skipped or missed, then let me know and I’ll take a look and see what I can do. I want to emphasise that you please let me know if someone hasn't given a constructive review. I do check some but not all so really you need to tell me. I am more than happy to do whatever I can to make sure you get a constructive review, that's what I'm here for. If the chain has continued on please still say something to me. I will always give a review to make up for skipped/unfair reviews, or any other issues, you just need to tell me please. The quickest way to let me know is to send me a private message. Please don’t post something in the topic where the chain is continuing, it will most likely make things confusing but please let me know any other way. 

There are different categories which you can post in:
- Short Stories
- Poems
- Novels
- Other
- Simple Reviews
In the Short Stories category you can only ask for short stories to be reviewed, in the Poems category you can only ask for poems to be reviewed, in the Novels category only novels. However in the Other category you can ask for anything to be reviewed. This can be scripts, essays, anything. You can also ask for stories, poems and novels to be reviewed in this section, it is open for everything. This is for the pieces that don't fit into the other categories but there isn't enough of that type going around to make it a separate category.
The Simple Reviews category is different to all the others, it is the place where reviews do not need to be constructive. This is for the people who still want to review but who may not have the time to give a constuctive review or don't want to give one. Any types of writing can be asked for; stories, scripts, etc. In the other categories I am happy to fix issues concerned with the quality of reviews, in the Simple Reviews category I won't be because there is no expected level of quality. I am of course more than happy to fix any issues with being skipped, or missed, so let me know about those. 

Not all of the categories appear on the homepage but they can accessed by clicking Forum.

On a sidenote please don't post irrelevant things to the forum topics already there. Whilst I want this to be a fun and friendly but this is not the place for random chats, games or seeking consolation for the loss of your pet rock. There's a General Chat topic and that is where you can do this but please keep it there.
If you want to advertise your writing without reviewing there's a topic called Writing Plugs where you can just ask people to review your writing, or mention a bit about it.


If anyone has any questions feel free to ask, I am more than happy to answer or explain anything. If anyone has any suggestions those are also very welcome.
If you want to give any feedback/ideas, etc. anonymously I've created a survey. You can say anything you want here:
https://www.surveymonkey.com/r/LDHVKZP

Thank you to those who have read through all these rules. If you haven’t read all the rules and just skipped to the end go back and read them (this is your second warning).
I hope everyone enjoys this and gets some great reviews from it.

2

Re: Rules (Read before doing anything else)

I am very glad that you posted these rule clarifications! I believe that if people will follow these suggestions & think about how they, themselves would want someone to review their own work, this format will be a very constructive way to aid all of us in promoting & enhancing our own work as well as helping others to do the same thing!
Once again, thank you! I'm happy to do anything I can to make this a better experience for anyone & everyone!

3

Re: Rules (Read before doing anything else)

Spyguy wrote:

I am very glad that you posted these rule clarifications! I believe that if people will follow these suggestions & think about how they, themselves would want someone to review their own work, this format will be a very constructive way to aid all of us in promoting & enhancing our own work as well as helping others to do the same thing!
Once again, thank you! I'm happy to do anything I can to make this a better experience for anyone & everyone!

Thank you Spyguy, I appreciate the effort you've spent with this house.

4

Re: Rules (Read before doing anything else)

You are very welcome! I love the idea of providing more input for each other! All of us benefit from that I think!

5

Re: Rules (Read before doing anything else)

Spyguy wrote:

You are very welcome! I love the idea of providing more input for each other! All of us benefit from that I think!

That's what I hope this house will do, the more that can benefit in any way the better.

6

Re: Rules (Read before doing anything else)

So, if I find a story sounds interesting, but its further down the chain and has passed, I can still read them, but they won't count towards the chain?

7

Re: Rules (Read before doing anything else)

blackheart38 wrote:

So, if I find a story sounds interesting, but its further down the chain and has passed, I can still read them, but they won't count towards the chain?

Yes, that's right. You have to review the person next in line (which is whoever has the last post), for it to count towards the chain. You're welcome to read any other stories that you find interesting, but unfortunately those don't count.

8

Re: Rules (Read before doing anything else)

Ok, thanks for clarifying

9

Re: Rules (Read before doing anything else)

I don't find the category here for poems, but I recently posted a poem here to this house, "Who do YOU see when you look in the Mirror?" I'd love to get some opinions on it!

10

Re: Rules (Read before doing anything else)

The topic for forums is here:
https://www.booksie.com/forums/topic67-poems-p2.html
I hope that helps

11

Re: Rules (Read before doing anything else)

I just wanted to add my thanks for posting the rules too.
I think this house will be really great and helpful because it will help us improve and we can give/get feedback.
Thank you for creating it.

12

Re: Rules (Read before doing anything else)

Jennifer Katherine wrote:

I just wanted to add my thanks for posting the rules too.
I think this house will be really great and helpful because it will help us improve and we can give/get feedback.
Thank you for creating it.

Welcome to the house! I'm very glad you think that, thanks very much for joining, I hope you find the house usefu.

13

Re: Rules (Read before doing anything else)

sure thing, the thought of helping others and receiving help as well is amazing.

14

Re: Rules (Read before doing anything else)

Read and understood. Thank you.

15

Re: Rules (Read before doing anything else)

I read the rules. Thanks. Looking forward to participating.

16

Re: Rules (Read before doing anything else)

I've read and understood the rules, I can't wait to participate!

17

Re: Rules (Read before doing anything else)

Hey thats a very interesting contest. Thank you for posting! I will look into it if i can put a chapter of SAVING MY SAVIOUR here for this contest

18

Re: Rules (Read before doing anything else)

Read the rules, con't belive it took me this long to even see that they were there, but I do think that the whole thing is a great idea, and thanks for posting the guidelines.

19

Re: Rules (Read before doing anything else)

kinda wish I noticed this before. I think I got it down though

20

Re: Rules (Read before doing anything else)

I've read the rules and I like how the reviewers need to be constructive about their comments. I'll submit my piece for the contest soon. smile

21

Re: Rules (Read before doing anything else)

Thanks everyone for reading the rules, I look forward to reading your entries.

22 (edited by WintertheWhiteWolf 2017-10-10 00:34:04)

Re: Rules (Read before doing anything else)

I read them all! smile Preparing just in case I want to enter the contest, I think I read this awhile ago, tho.

23

Re: Rules (Read before doing anything else)

I've read all the rules and will try to submit an entry to the contest soon.

24

Re: Rules (Read before doing anything else)

I've read the rules and I'll (hopefully) be submitting my entry soon.

25

Re: Rules (Read before doing anything else)

Greythereadaholic wrote:

I've read the rules and I'll (hopefully) be submitting my entry soon.

Thanks for reading the rules and I look forward to your entry.