Controlling People

Book Review by: Equanimity

Summary

Review of "Controlling People" by Patricia Evans

Content

Submitted: November 23, 2012

A A A | A A A

Content

Submitted: November 23, 2012

A A A

A A A


Evans does a brilliant job of coming up with a simple recipe for communicating this dynamic. This book is very helpful and worthwhile. The book introduced me to the idea of psychic boundaries - that is everything that is me that is unseen - my energy, spirit, ideas, thoughts, soul, etc. and the idea of creating a boundary around these parts of myself being as important as having physical boundaries. Evans also does a great job of describing how we come to define ourselves from the outside in - having early influences negate our experience of self and redefine us, thereby teaching us to "act backwards" and define ourselves from the outside.  

Where the book leaves off or falls short - and readers should know this - is in conveying the psychological complexity that goes with this dynamic. Evans' approach, which is communicative vs psychological, is largely black and white, where the "Controller" is portrayed as the unhealthy bad guy who is under a spell, and the "Witness" is portrayed as the healthy, innocent bystander who lives with the spellbound person. I believe this theory is too simple to be realistic.  It leaves "Witnesses" without any real understanding of their role in the dynamic - why are they there in the first place and how can they avoid making the same choices again? With no understanding of these things, the "Witness" is truly a victim.  The book can leave "Controllers" feeling shamed, when in reality, they deserve compassion - it is essential in the healing process. Evans conveys compassion for "Witnesses" but not for "Controllers". Evans asserts that "Controllers" are a minority of people and that most other people are not cut off from themselves. Because Evans is generalizing based on extremes, this is true.  In reality, there is a huge continuum - people play the "Controller" and the "Witness" at different times, with different people, and in different ways.  People are cut off from themselves in some ways and not in others. If "Witnesses" were healthy, why would they be in relationships with "Controllers" - wouldn't their intact sense of self direct them out of such a relationship?  

This book is a worthwhile read, but the reader should keep in mind that Evans' approach is not psychological and the simplification of this dynamic is for communication purposes only. In reality the dynamic is complex, requires compassion, and an understanding that everyone plays a part - there are no innocent bystanders. The book is a starting point. It is not an Rx for understanding and dealing with this dynamic, but it is a helpful tool in the process of awakening.


 

 


© Copyright 2016 Equanimity. All rights reserved.

Controlling People Controlling People

Status: Finished

Genre: Other

Houses:

Details

Status: Finished

Genre: Other

Houses:

Summary

Review of "Controlling People" by Patricia Evans
Share :
Twitter

Add Your Comments:

Other Content by Equanimity

Booksie Popular Content

Genres & Types

Add picture

Paste the link to picture in the entry below:

— or —

Drag a picture from your file manager into this box,
or click to select.

Add video

Paste the link to Youtube video in the following entry:

Existing Comments:
Bad selection

Cannot annotate a non-flat selection. Make sure your selection starts and ends within the same node.

(example of bad selection): This is bold text and this is normal text.
(example of good selection): This is bold text and this is normal text.
Bad selection

An annotation cannot contain another annotation.

Anonymous
Really delete this comment?
Anonymous
Really delete this comment?

There was an error uploading your file.


    
Anonymous